Joanne Nova’s approach to climate science is to cast doubt on what we do know, rather than present facts that would counter the scientific concensus. It’s a tactic used by tobacco companies, and now climate denialists are doing the same.
On Nova’s website are posts of political nature, now and again she will present science in an attempt to mislead her readers into thinking that warming is not happening, or that it’s happening but it’s not greenhouse gases, or that it’s happening but nothing to be concerned about. Below are a number of contradictions, cherry picking examples and finally a list of Nova’s topics that I am slowly working my way through and providing the rebuttal.
Nova’s attempts to cast doubt on the science of global warming and in doing so presents many contradicting theories. Some say it’s not warming, some say it’s warming and it’s the sun, some say it’s warming and it the oceans, some say it’s just all a hoax.
Nova misleads her reader by only selecting small bit of science or data that supports her political position. This results in a contrived position that becomes all too obvious
Nova’s “Science” Posts
Amongst her myriad of politically motivated posts, Joanne Nova occasionally will slip one in about the science. Unfortunately, as we’ll see, Nova’s science is founded more on web-blogger do-it-yourself, rather than on the peer-reviewed process which has been fundamental to bringing science to where it is today. I’ll continue to debunk Joanne Nova and her brand of science. Check back here over time – I’ll continue to grow this list.
Sep 2008, Releases her handbook – and prematurely announces that there’s no more warming ( wrong ) and that CO2 is only plant food ( wrong ).
Oct 2008 – The missing hotspot – or missing logic?
Jan 2009 – Reply to Deltoid – Repeat past errors.
Jan 2009 – Even gurus of warming – Nova repeat errors again.
Apr 2009, Akasofu Wave Theory – Nova now says it’s warming, says it oscillates, but can’t find a physical cause.
Dec 2009, Fraudulent Hockey Sticks, or flawed CO2Science, a fraudulent Loehle graph and misinterpreted Huang.
Feb 2010, CO2 can’t have much warming effect but cherry picks a flawed low climate sensitivity paper.
Feb 2010, 65 million years of temperature swings – shows how vulnerable life is
Apr 2010, No, Dr Glikson, Yes Jo Nova.
Jun 2010, How John Cook points out Nova’s repeated errors.
Jul 2010, Sherwood 2008 – found the hotspot.
Jul 2010, The Unskeptical Guide – found the hotspot.
Aug 2010, It’s everything except CO2 – and failed to spot the numerous contradictions.
Aug 2010, The models are wrong – the average of all models is wrong.
Sep 2010, The Temperature is Adjusted by 70% – but they failed to account for site change.
Nov 2010, Dessler – Nova gets Spurious.
Nov 2010 – Thorne – Found non fundamental disagreement between models and observations.
March 2011, David Evans, ROCKET SCIENTIST! – Or just an old guy repeating old myths.
May 2011, Bob Carter speaks – but not very well.
Jul 2011, Australian sea levels slow – or do they?
Nov 2011, Cite’s the Schmittner paper as evidence for low climate sensitivity – then disagree’s with herself once I remind her of her previous words.
Oct 2011, This is 90% certainty – the hotspot is mentioned, Nova didn’t notice.
Dec 2011, Says the oceans are missing heat – but cherry picks once more.
Jan 2012, It’s the PDO. – but is fooled by their own equation.
Mar 2012, Suggests temperature records are shoddy, inaccurate, unreliable – but failed basics statistics.
Apr 2012, Likes Idso’s low climate sensitivity but didn’t realise we’ve already exceeded that.
Apr 2012, Praises Lindzen & Choi – but is ignorant of their mistakes.
Apr 2012, Compares 30 years of temperature rise – forgot about equilibrium, other forcings and got the math wrong.
Apr 2012, Praises Spencer – but is still ignorant.
Apr 2012, Fingerprint or Signature? – Both but not Unique.
May 2012, Models get the core assumptions – but it’s not an assumption.
Jun 2012, Says the BOM get’s it all wrong – but Nova repeats an earlier mistake.
Jul 2012, The big news is out, WUWT – failed to deliver.
Sep 2012, The Models aren’t 100% correct – and we don’t ever expect themto be.
Sep 2012, Raises Alarm on Antarctic Ice – at a time when Arctic is at 50% levels.
Oct 2012, declares Warming has been Disproved, so long as you ignore the evidence.
Oct 2012, Says One croal adapts and ignores the rest.
Oct 2012, Can’t understand Antarctic Melt – even though it seemed well explained.
Nov 2012, Gets Jealous about NewBy – and produced the usual myths.
Dec 2012, Examines Fasullo and Trenberth – and fails.
Dec 2012, Says sea levels are NOT rising – but forgot about the evidence.
Jan 2013, 2 Million Years Ago – Things were very different.
Jan 2013, What Heatwave – This one.
Jan 2013, Alice is not unusual – It’s not Australia either.
Jan 2013, 8 reasons a Heatwave is not Global Warming – No, it’s not aliens.
Feb 2013, Yet another paper – found the hotspot.
Mar 2013, Not the hottest – Mother Nature mocks Nova.
Mar 2013, Has the World started cooling? – Nope. But Nova flunks Stats 101.
Apr 2013, AR5 Hidey Games – Nova still ignores majority of data.
Apr 2013, Antarctica is gaining Mass – Nova’s confused once more.